10 thoughts on “Civil War Casualties”

1. This article of Andrew Johnson’s drunkeness is just too funny. Can you imagine if that would happen in 2011. Very interesting history. Lee.

   Reply

2. David Hacker says that the death toll was 750,000. I hope he is wrong.

   Reply

3. As an American citizen that is studying war, having fought in the Vietnam War, I say that our country went through a horrible and tragic civil war during the 1860s.

   The total deaths may never be accurately known, but one American killing another for the actual cause of the war was unnecessary and downright insensible. Since the beginning of our Nation, America has only been at peace for 30 years.

   I can only surmise that this trend will continue, to make the 1% of this Nation’s richest, more wealthier, without taking bids as it did in the Iraq Wars.

   It is asked, when did “all men are created equal”, ever realized in America — and continues to be brushed under the rug? The founding fathers of this Nation should have written, the most wealthiest of our Nation, the top 1%, are the only ones “created equal”, because we see the other 99% of our population bending to the elite 1%.

   Reply

   • Fact is, when the Declaration of Independence (a secessionist document) was written, the word equality did not mean what it means this day. Word’s definitions change over tyme. And it is not always for the best. Consider "gay". Back when, it meant happy and free. Now, it mainly refers to homosexual males.

     Equality though applied to White European based males, was not evenly dispersed even then. The Framers of the DoI and the Constitution included not one single "average Joe", so to say. Nor women. Nor Indians. Nor Coloured People/People of Colour.

     Of compelling interest is – what was the British perspective of that conflict, both back then, and nowadays? Certainly they thought differently, had differing opinions of why the colonials were so angered, so NOT at peace with the crown that they wanted to break free. Consider this link: https://www.theodysseyonline.com/british-perspective-american-revolution

     Reply

4. This site would be best used to show respect for the loss of life and limb. Not to berate others with liberals, out of touch with reality veiws. Raymond, you are the 1% trying to convince 99% of your socialistic agenda.
   I beleive this site is to teach us how inhumane and horrible the civil war was.

   Reply

5. Mr. Docker,

   Thank you for your comments regarding your opinion.

   However, I don’t recall ever asking for your opinion! Opinions are just like…….., we all have one. I didn’t ask for your opinion and your insinuation about my not having respect for the dead military in war is in itself very distasteful to me and burns my face.

   My first sentence in my comment was very much in align with the horrific nature of war. My other comments was right on, but one or two statements you deem socialist, does not make a socialist with an agenda.

   I have no agenda, nor do I desire one, other than to awake people like you to what has happened to these Divided States of America. But these sleeping citizens shall one day be awaken prior to the crap hitting the fan when they will be killed on the streets of America by Americans again.

   Marines and other military personnel fight for our Constitution against “all enemies, both foreign and domestic”. I deem myself a patriot, but even a patriot has the right to speak his mind in a public forum when he sees his beloved Country going down the tubes.

   And, Mr. Docker, if you and others don’t see America going down the tubes, there are some people out in La La Land that would be more than happy to sell you the Brooklyn Bridge.

   Maybe you should attempt to read and decipher the Constitution, or what’s left of it, regarding people like you attempting to take the freedoms away from the citizens of the Divided States of America — like free speech in a public forum.

   I am not socialist one iota and you are the first person to ever accuse me of one. I am only an outspoken human being desiring to be treated like you desire to treat the dead — with respect.

   I am also a Vietnam War and Cold War Marine that doesn’t like to be addressed the way you did me, with the tone you did.

   Tell me, Mr. Docker, did you ever serve in the Military? Did you ever go to war? Did you ever see dead Marines and soldiers come from the battle field, almost every day that you were in a war zone? Or did you run somewhere or get deferment after deferment to stay out of the war, letting men like me fight for your liberties?

   I saw the dead heroes being dropped off at the morgue, almost every single day by my squadron.

   So, Mr. Docker, you can take your unwanted comment about my “respect” along with your right to state whatever you desire, and jam it where the sun doesn’t shine into an aperture or orifice of your body that no one cares to see.

   Just as you made your opinions known to me, I am now making my opinions known to you, in the same forum.

   Furthermore, never address me by name again as I will construe it to be harassment and if I were you, I would also determine what any person is all about prior to addressing him or her in an open forum. I tell it like I see it, and like it is also recorded in History books.

   Ignorance is bliss, Mr. Docker, but ignorance is no excuse to attempt to pull the wool over people’s eyes by revealing your ignorance.

   I am not a socialist by any means of the stretch of the imagination. What I am is a United States Marine Corps, Vietnam and Cold War Veteran that takes offense to what you stated. Sixty-six of my fellow comrades-in-arms were killed in Vietnam and the Korean Wars and someone with the likes of you dares to call me down and state what you did about me in a public forum.

   I would like to give you a lesson, just like you attempted to give me. War is hell, whether it is the Civil War or just a war with a banana republic. It causes more than physical wounds that may never heal.

   So if I were you, I would be very careful in what you say to someone you do not know and only hypothesize about, making an unsound judgment by stating what you did.

   Mr. Docker, have you been to war, have you ever had to experience the effect of war, not only to

   Reply

6. If anyone has to be taught that war in inhumane and how horrible the Civil War was, may God have mercy upon their souls.

   Reply

7. War, any war, is hell for the victims that are wounded, that are killed, that are maimed, and for those that see and do things which they would never do outside of war. Some injuries are unseen and can actually show up many years after the victim has been injured.

   War is also devastating to those left behind, lives put on hold because a government has called their love one to duty, having the wife of the called, to go on without her husband and do what she can to keep a family together while he is gone.

   War is hell when the government refuses to honor their own contract with those that served. That my readers has been a reality as it has been for every war that America has ever fought in. I ask, how does this action by our government honor the dead military personnel and those that still live maimed and changed for life?

   Reply

8. Is there a published list of those Enlisted Union Soldiers who were executed along with reason for such punishment?

   Reply

   • I’m not aware of such a list, but that doesn’t mean that there isn’t one.

     Reply